Duane Buziak Explains Low Credit Score Mortgage Options in Hanover County, VA

Duane Buziak Mortgage Maestro explains how low credit score mortgage lenders handle a 620 score in Hanover County, VA, using worked FHA and conventional payment examples on a $350,000 home. You will see how 20 points can move a monthly payment by about $166 and what that means for your loan choice.
Hanover County Home Purchase Loan: Every Program Explained — Mortgage Broker Serving Mechanicsville, Ashland & Atlee
Duane Buziak

Duane Buziak
Mortgage Maestro | NMLS #1110647 | Coast2Coast Mortgage LLC
Licensed Mortgage Broker serving Virginia, Florida, Tennessee, Georgia, and Washington, specializing in VA home loans and first-time homebuyer programs.

Suppose a buyer in Mechanicsville, VA has a 620 middle score and wants a $350,000 home. Here is the FHA version, with every assumption stated: 3.5% down is $12,250, so the base loan is $337,750. The upfront mortgage insurance premium (MIP) is 1.75%, or $5,911, financed into the loan for a total of $343,661 over 30 years. At an assumed 6.75% interest rate, principal and interest come to about $2,229. Add annual MIP of 0.55% ($155 a month), property tax at an assumed 0.80 per $100 of value ($233) and homeowners insurance at an assumed $120, and the payment is about $2,737. Because the MIP is financed, the APR runs higher than the 6.75% note rate.

Now a conventional loan at 5% down ($332,500 loan), using hypothetical pricing. At a 620 score, assume a 7.00% interest rate and private mortgage insurance (PMI) at 1.40% a year. That works out to $2,212 in principal and interest plus $388 in PMI, or about $2,953 with the same tax and insurance. At 640, assume 6.75% and PMI at 1.00%: $2,157 plus $277, or about $2,787. Twenty points moved this illustration by roughly $166 a month. Real pricing varies by lender and day, but the direction is real.

Duane Buziak Mortgage Maestro, NMLS #1110647, shops your loan across hundreds of wholesale lenders. No single “low credit score lender” exists. The work is choosing the right program and preparing the file so it fits.

1. Match the Loan Program to Your Score

Each program prices risk differently, which is why the same score can look strong in one and weak in another. As of 2026, HUD sets FHA tiers at 3.5% down for scores of 580 and up, and 10% down for scores of 500 to 579. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac conventional loans generally start around a 620 score; confirm the current floor in the Fannie Mae Selling Guide. VA loans, backed by VA.gov, set no minimum score of their own, though lenders add their own. USDA eligibility depends on the property address, checked on the official USDA map.

The structure of mortgage insurance matters as much as the score. FHA charges an upfront premium plus annual MIP. Conventional PMI is priced by score and down payment, and it can be removed once you reach enough equity. At a 620 score on $350,000, the FHA illustration above ($2,737) can land below the conventional one ($2,953) even with less money down. At 680, that comparison can flip.

To put it into practice:

  1. Gather your middle score, available down payment and gross monthly income.
  2. Have Duane Buziak run the same scenario through each program that fits, including VA with the Certificate of Eligibility pulled electronically on your behalf, and second-tier entitlement if you used VA before.
  3. Compare payment, insurance and cash to close side by side.

The common mistake is assuming conventional is always better, or ruling out FHA because of a myth that it is only for desperate buyers. Measure total monthly payment and cash to close for each program on the identical scenario.

2. Use a Broker Who Shops Wholesale Lenders

An overlay is a lender’s own rule layered on top of the program’s minimum. The program may allow a 600 score while one lender requires 640. Because overlays differ lender to lender, a decline from one is not a verdict on your file.

For illustration only, imagine a borrower with a 610 middle score and a clean payment history. One lender’s overlay requires 640 for her loan type and turns her away. Another follows the program floor and fits her file. Her credit did not change; the guidelines did. A retail lender such as Rocket Mortgage or Movement Mortgage originates under its own guidelines, which is a legitimate model. A broker’s structural difference is access to many lenders’ guidelines from one application. Duane Buziak also has direct wholesale access through Lower, LLC’s wholesale arm, PowerTPO, without a retail markup, and that makes no claim of a pricing advantage.

This is where “Dare to Compare” comes in. Ask for a written scenario across multiple lenders and compare it line by line:

  • Interest rate and APR
  • Mortgage insurance type and monthly amount
  • Lender fees and credits
  • Cash to close

The common mistake is applying with several lenders in a row without a plan, and assuming they all share the same rules. Each application can add inquiries and confusion. Measure how many programs your file fits and whether you hold a written comparison of costs.

3. Run a NoTouch Credit Pull First

The NoTouch Credit Pull is a soft pull pre-approval: no credit hit, no cost, no fees and no commitment. A soft inquiry does not affect your score, so you learn where you stand before any hard inquiry is made.

For illustration, imagine a buyer in Ashland, VA near Randolph-Macon College who is unsure whether her 600s score points to FHA, VA or conventional. A soft pull pre-approval shows which programs her file fits and a realistic price range. She can then house hunt knowing the target, rather than guessing after a hard pull she may not need.

To start:

  1. Call 804-212-8663 to begin.
  2. Provide basic income and debt details for the soft pull.
  3. Review the program and price-range answer with Duane Buziak.

The pitfall is letting several lenders pull hard credit before you know your target program. Checking your own credit does not hurt your score, and a soft pull is the same kind of look. Hard inquiries for a mortgage are generally grouped when made within a short shopping window, but a window is not a plan. Measure success by getting a clear program and price-range answer with no change to your score.

4. Read the Middle Score

There is no single credit score. Lenders pull three, one each from Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, and typically use the middle one rather than the highest. A free app showing one number can sit well above or below what a lender sees, because different scoring models are in play.

Take scores of 618, 631 and 644. The qualifying score is 631. With two borrowers on one loan, lenders generally take each borrower’s middle score and then use the lower of the two. If your co-borrower’s middle score is 598, the file qualifies at 598 even if yours is 631. That can change program eligibility and pricing, and sometimes it points to a single-borrower application.

To put it into practice:

  1. Ask Duane Buziak for a tri-merge view, which merges all three bureaus’ data into one report.
  2. Identify the qualifying middle score.
  3. Compare it against program floors (such as 580) and pricing breaks, which often come at steps like 620, 640 and 660.

The common mistake is trusting a free app score as the qualifying score, then being surprised in underwriting. Measure the gap between your qualifying middle score and the nearest threshold. If you sit 6 points under a pricing break, that is a very different conversation from 40 points under.

5. Pull Reports and Fix Errors

Credit reports contain mistakes more often than most people expect: accounts that belong to someone else, balances not updated, or debts listed twice. Correcting a genuine error can raise a score without any change in behavior. Accurate negative items cannot be removed by dispute, and they do not need to be removed for you to buy.

For illustration, imagine a collection account on your report that belongs to a person with a similar name. You dispute it with the bureau in writing, attaching proof. The CFPB publishes the dispute process and sample letters, and the bureau generally must investigate. If the item is removed, the middle score may rise.

The steps:

  1. Pull your reports free at AnnualCreditReport.com, the federally authorized source.
  2. Mark every item you do not recognize or that looks wrong.
  3. Dispute in writing with each bureau that shows it, and send copies of supporting records.
  4. Keep a log of dates, letters and responses.
  5. Tell Duane Buziak before a rapid rescore or any payoff, so timing fits your loan.

The common mistakes are paying a company for credit repair and disputing accurate items, which wastes weeks. Measure errors resolved and the updated middle score.

6. Lower Your DTI

Debt-to-income ratio (DTI) is your monthly debt payments divided by gross monthly income. Underwriters weigh it alongside the score, so a stronger DTI and cash reserves can offset a weaker score. The reverse also holds: a high DTI on a low score narrows your options fast.

Take $6,000 in monthly income. With $2,100 in total monthly debts, including the new housing payment, back-end DTI is 35%. At $2,700, it is 45%. Paying off a $350 car payment or a card with a $120 minimum could move you across that line, but the effect on your score differs by account type. A card payoff can lift the score as well, while an installment loan payoff may not.

To put it into practice:

  1. List every debt with its balance and monthly payment.
  2. Ask Duane Buziak which payoff moves the ratio and the score most.
  3. Sequence payoffs with the loan timeline before paying anything.

The common mistake is closing old accounts or opening new credit mid-process. A new account adds an inquiry and a payment, and a closed card can shorten your credit history and raise utilization. Measure back-end DTI before and after, along with your reserves counted in months of full housing payments.

7. Plan Down Payment and Closing Costs

A bigger down payment does not fix everything, but it does change the loan. On $350,000, 3.5% down is $12,250 and 10% is $35,000. The base loan drops from $337,750 to $315,000, which in the earlier 6.75% illustration trims principal and interest by roughly $150 a month. Check HUD.gov for current tiers, since a 500 to 579 score requires the 10% level on FHA.

Closing costs are a separate hurdle. Ask about no-out-of-pocket closing options, which can include seller credits and lender credits within program limits. Those credits are capped, not unlimited, and a lender credit often comes with a higher interest cost.

The steps:

  1. Check eligibility for Virginia Housing programs, including its credit minimums.
  2. Ask which seller and lender credits apply to your loan type.
  3. Set a cash-to-close target and a reserve target.

The common mistake is stacking assistance programs without confirming they can be used together, or counting on credits that exceed the program cap. Measure cash to close against the funds you can document, including seasoning (how long money has sat in your account).

8. Document Non-Traditional Income

Self-employed and variable income is usually averaged, and underwriters count what your tax returns show, not what you earned before deductions. That is where good contractors and business owners lose qualifying income.

For illustration, imagine a contractor in Beaverdam, VA with two years of returns and a year-to-date profit and loss statement. His gross receipts look strong, but heavy write-offs cut his taxable income. The average of the two years, adjusted for allowable add-backs like depreciation, is the number his loan is built on.

To prepare:

  1. Gather two years of personal and business returns.
  2. Prepare a year-to-date profit and loss statement.
  3. Collect 12 to 24 months of business bank statements, if the program calls for them.
  4. Write a short explanation for any large or unusual deposits.

The common mistakes are aggressive write-offs the year before you apply, and unexplained transfers between accounts. A conversation with your tax preparer before you file can matter more than anything done after. Measure your qualifying monthly income against the income needed to carry the target payment at your DTI limit.

9. Decide Whether to Close Now or Improve First

Waiting is a decision with a price. So is buying before the numbers work. The way to settle it is to compare two specific payments.

For illustration, imagine your middle score is 6 points under a pricing break and one credit card is at 85% utilization. A 3-month plan to pay that card down could lift the score past the break. Using the earlier hypothetical, a 20-point move was worth roughly $166 a month. Against that, add the cost of waiting: rent paid in the meantime, and the chance prices or costs shift.

To compare:

  1. Get the payment today from Duane Buziak.
  2. Get the projected payment after the specific fix.
  3. Add the county property tax. The real estate tax rate is published by Hanover County, and the illustration here used an assumed figure.
  4. If you are building new, add the construction timeline, since the rate lock and your credit need to hold until closing.

The common mistakes are waiting with no specific action, and buying before the payment feels comfortable. Measure the payment difference between buying now and after the improvement, against the cost of waiting.

Where to Start When Your Score Is Under 640

Begin with a NoTouch Credit Pull and a program match, items 3 and 1. Then shop the file across lenders and review your reports for errors, items 2 and 5. After that, work on DTI and funds planning. Duane Buziak Mortgage Maestro has been helping families find their new homes since 2014, with 2,000+ verified reviews across all platforms.

Ready to see what you qualify for in Hanover County? Duane Buziak, VA Broker of the Year 2024 & 2025 and Scotsman Guide Top Originator, runs a soft credit check first so there’s no hard inquiry on your credit report. Call 804-212-8663 or apply online. Duane Buziak NMLS #1110647 | Coast2Coast Mortgage LLC NMLS #376205 | Equal Housing Opportunity.

Share:

More Posts

Conventional Loan vs FHA: Which Fits?

Duane Buziak Explains Mortgage Refinance Options in Hanover County, VA

Duane Buziak Mortgage Maestro, NMLS #1110647, explains mortgage refinance options for Hanover County, VA homeowners, starting with a worked $300,000 example comparing 7.0% and 6.0% payments. The guide matches each goal, whether a lower payment, shorter term, cash, or dropping mortgage insurance, to the refinance type and the cost test that shows whether it pays off in 2026.

Send Us A Message