Duane Buziak Explains FHA vs. Conventional Loans in Hanover County, VA

Duane Buziak Mortgage Maestro, NMLS #1110647, walks through an FHA vs conventional loan comparison using a $400,000 Mechanicsville, VA home. The worked example shows down payment, upfront and monthly mortgage insurance, and the full monthly payment for FHA at 3.5% down and conventional at 3% and 5% down, so Hanover County buyers can see how the structures differ before choosing.
Hanover County Adjustable Rate Mortgage: What Local Buyers in Mechanicsville, Ashland & Atlee Need to Know
Duane Buziak

Duane Buziak
Mortgage Maestro | NMLS #1110647 | Coast2Coast Mortgage LLC
Licensed Mortgage Broker serving Virginia, Florida, Tennessee, Georgia, and Washington, specializing in VA home loans and first-time homebuyer programs.

Illustration only: suppose you are buying a $400,000 home in Mechanicsville, VA, with a 30-year loan. Here is how three common starting points differ before anyone talks about a note rate.

  • FHA at 3.5% down: $14,000 down, $386,000 base loan, plus an upfront mortgage insurance premium (MIP) of 1.75%, which is $6,755 added to the balance. Total loan: $392,755. Annual MIP is about $177 a month (0.55% a year on the base loan, as of 2026).
  • Conventional at 3% down: $12,000 down, $388,000 loan, no upfront premium. Monthly private mortgage insurance (PMI) at a placeholder 0.55% is about $178.
  • Conventional at 5% down: $20,000 down, $380,000 loan, no upfront premium. PMI at a placeholder 0.40% is about $127 a month.

Assumptions for all three: a 6.50% note rate on a 30-year term, property tax at an assumed 0.80% of price ($267 a month), and homeowners insurance of $1,500 a year ($125 a month). The PMI percentages are placeholders, not quotes, and APR will differ from the note rate. Principal and interest plus insurance and tax put the full monthly payment near $3,051 for FHA, $3,022 for conventional at 3% down, and $2,920 for conventional at 5% down.

The loan with the smaller down payment is not automatically the cheaper one, and the gap depends on your credit, how long mortgage insurance lasts, and what you plan to do next. Below are six decision strategies, in the order I work through them, followed by a side-by-side FHA vs. conventional loan comparison table. I’m Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647, and I have been helping families find their new homes since 2014.

In this article

1. Start With Your Credit Score Tier, Not the Loan Name

Consider an illustration with placeholder numbers. Two buyers purchase the same $400,000 home with 5% down on a conventional loan. At a 740 score, PMI might price near 0.40% a year, about $127 a month. At a 640 score, the same loan might price near 1.40%, about $443 a month. Under FHA, the annual MIP follows a schedule based on loan size, term and loan-to-value (LTV, the loan divided by the home’s value), not your score, so it stays near $177 for both buyers. At 740, conventional looks cheaper. At 640, FHA can win.

That is why credit tier is the first filter. FHA is built to be more forgiving: HUD’s Handbook 4000.1 sets a 580 minimum score for 3.5% down, with 500 to 579 requiring 10% down. Conventional lenders commonly look for 620 or higher, and pricing improves sharply as scores climb. Guidelines change, so confirm current FHA loan credit score requirements before you decide. Note that FHA is not “only for low credit.” Plenty of buyers with strong scores choose it for the down payment or the DTI treatment covered later.

Putting it into practice:

  1. Request a NoTouch Credit Pull soft pull pre-approval. That is a pre-approval review with no credit hit, no cost, no fees and no commitment.
  2. Read the score and the report together. Look for errors and for recent late payments, not just the number.
  3. Ask me to quote FHA and conventional from the same file, since I shop your loan across hundreds of wholesale lenders.

The common mistake is choosing a program from a friend’s story. Their score, down payment and timeline are not yours. Measure the side-by-side monthly payment and the 5-year total cost, including mortgage insurance, for each program at your actual score.

2. Compare Mortgage Insurance Over the Years You Will Actually Hold the Loan

FHA charges mortgage insurance in two parts. The upfront MIP is 1.75% of the base loan, so on a $386,000 base loan it is $6,755, financed into the balance (illustration). The annual MIP is billed monthly. Under current HUD rules, with less than 10% down on a 30-year loan, annual MIP runs for the life of the loan. With 10% or more down it ends after 11 years. Check the HUD.gov schedule for what applies as of 2026, and see how this plays out in FHA loans in Hanover County.

Conventional PMI works differently. There is no upfront premium on the typical monthly-pay structure, and under the Homeowners Protection Act you can request cancellation at 80% of the original value and it ends automatically at 78%, as the CFPB explains. Lender requirements, such as payment history, apply.

A rough illustration of cumulative insurance, using the placeholder PMI of 0.40% at 5% down:

  • 5 years: FHA roughly $17,000 (upfront plus annual MIP); conventional roughly $7,600.
  • 10 years: FHA roughly $26,000; conventional roughly $15,000, near when PMI could end.
  • 15 years: FHA roughly $35,000 and still running; conventional stops at its removal point.

The FHA total includes the financed $6,755, so the loan balance, and its interest, is slightly larger too. Real quotes will move every figure above.

Steps:

  1. Get written quotes for both programs.
  2. Total the insurance cost at 5, 10 and 15 years.
  3. Mark the month PMI would end, using your payment schedule and realistic appreciation.
  4. Decide whether you will likely sell or refinance before then.

The mistake is comparing only the first-year monthly payment. FHA can look close early and cost far more by year ten. What to measure: cumulative mortgage insurance paid at your expected hold period. Also, FHA insurance is not literally permanent, since selling or refinancing ends it.

3. Count Cash to Close, Not Just the Down Payment

On a $400,000 home, the down payment is $14,000 for FHA at 3.5%, $12,000 for conventional at 3%, and $20,000 for conventional at 5% (illustration). Those figures are before closing costs, prepaids (taxes and insurance collected at closing), and escrow deposits. If I assume a placeholder $12,000 for those items, cash to close lands near $26,000 for FHA, $24,000 for conventional at 3%, and $32,000 for conventional at 5%. The FHA upfront MIP is financed, so it does not add to cash at the table.

Several things can change the total:

  • Seller concessions: as of 2026, FHA generally allows up to 6% of the price, while conventional caps vary by down payment, starting at 3% when you put down less than 10%.
  • Gift funds: allowed under both programs with documentation, with rules that differ by program.
  • Assistance programs: Virginia Housing publishes its own eligibility, income and credit rules, and those change.

To work through it:

  1. Request a Loan Estimate for each program. It is the standardized form that shows estimated cash to close.
  2. Compare Section K and the total at the bottom, not just the down payment line.
  3. Check which concession limits and assistance options fit your price and program.
  4. Subtract cash to close from your savings to see what remains.

The mistake is assuming the lowest down payment means the lowest cash to close. A conventional loan at 3% down can need less cash than FHA, as the numbers above show. Measure the total cash to close on the Loan Estimate and the reserves left afterward. Many buyers like to keep several months of payments in the bank after closing. For a full walkthrough of program basics, see this Hanover County home purchase loan guide.

4. Match the Loan to How You Document Your Income and Debts

The mistake to avoid here comes first: assuming a pre-approval for one program carries over to the other. It does not, because each has its own underwriting rules.

Debt-to-income (DTI) is your monthly debt payments, including the new housing payment, divided by gross monthly income. Both programs allow DTI above the traditional 43% with strong compensating factors, such as reserves or a steady job history, and the ceilings and automated-underwriting treatment differ. They also count some debts differently, such as student loans in deferment or income-driven repayment. The Hanover County home loan requirements breakdown covers documentation in more detail.

Consider an illustration. A Mechanicsville buyer earns $9,000 a month with a $450 car payment and a $300 student loan payment. Using the FHA payment of $3,051 from the opening example, DTI is ($3,051 + $450 + $300) / $9,000, or about 42%. If she pays off the car and goes conventional at 5% down ($2,920), DTI is ($2,920 + $300) / $9,000, or about 36%. But paying off the car uses cash that might otherwise cover closing or reserves, so run it both ways.

Putting it into practice:

  1. Gather two years of tax returns or W-2s, recent pay stubs, and a list of every debt with balances and payments.
  2. If you are self-employed, expect lenders to average net income over two years, so deductions matter.
  3. Have both programs run through underwriting rather than guessing.

Measure the DTI under each program, and whether it leaves room for compensating factors if your numbers sit near a limit.

5. Check the Property: Appraisal Standards and New Construction in Atlee Station

FHA appraisals apply HUD minimum property standards, so condition can decide the loan. Illustration: an older Ashland home with a worn roof or peeling paint could be flagged for repair before an FHA loan can close. Conventional appraisals still note health and safety issues, but the standards are generally less condition-driven. Buyers in town can also read about Ashland VA home loans and the options available there.

A new build in Atlee Station usually meets condition standards. The risk there is time. Construction delays can run past a rate-lock period, which can mean extension costs, so confirm the builder’s completion timeline against your lock. The Hanover County new construction loan guide explains how timing and financing fit together.

Before you write an offer

  1. Tour with a condition checklist covering roof, paint, handrails, drainage, heating and water.
  2. Confirm the loan program with your lender before the offer goes in.
  3. Verify loan limits for the Richmond metropolitan area at fhfa.gov and hud.gov. Both are updated annually, and a $400,000 home sits well under most limits, but larger purchases may not.

The common mistake is making an offer before checking whether the home’s condition fits the chosen loan. That can cost you repair negotiations or a deal. Measure the appraisal condition findings, and the days remaining before closing against your contract deadline and lock.

6. Plan Your Exit: FHA Now, Conventional Refinance Later

Some buyers start with FHA and refinance into a conventional loan once credit and equity improve. If the new loan is at or below 80% LTV, PMI is not required, which ends the mortgage insurance. It is a plan, not a promise. For more on how the conventional side works, see this Hanover County conventional loan overview.

The test is break-even. Divide refinance closing costs by the monthly payment change. Placeholder illustration: closing costs of $6,000 and a monthly drop of $210 gives about 29 months. If you expect to stay longer than that, the refinance may be worthwhile.

Equity is the harder part. Using the opening numbers, after four years of payments you might owe around $373,000. To reach 80% LTV, the home would need to be worth about $466,000. That is a placeholder, and values can fall as well as rise.

  1. Track home equity and your credit score once a year.
  2. Compare refinance quotes as LTV approaches 80%.
  3. Compute break-even before deciding, using actual costs.

The mistake is counting on a future refinance without allowing for changing market costs and home values. Treat it as a bonus, not the basis of the original choice. Measure break-even months versus how long you expect to stay.

FHA vs. Conventional Loan: Side-by-Side Comparison

Figures reflect general guidelines as of 2026. Programs, limits and lender overlays change, so confirm before you rely on any row.

FeatureFHAConventional
Minimum down payment3.5% with a 580+ score; 10% for 500 to 579As low as 3% on some programs; 5% is common; 20% avoids PMI
Credit scoreMore forgiving at lower tiersCommonly 620 or higher; pricing improves as scores rise
Upfront mortgage insurance1.75% of base loan, usually financedNone on typical monthly PMI
Ongoing insuranceAnnual MIP, billed monthly; schedule set by HUDPMI priced by score, down payment and loan size
When insurance endsLife of loan under 10% down; 11 years with 10% or more downRequest at 80% LTV; automatic at 78%
Effect of credit on insurance costLittle, since the schedule is not score-basedLarge
DTI treatmentFlexible with compensating factorsFlexible with strong profile; different debt counting
Property conditionHUD minimum standards can require repairsGenerally less condition-driven
Seller concessionsUp to 6% of price3% to 9%, depending on down payment
Exit optionsRefinance to conventional can end MIPPMI ends on its own at set LTV points

Ten Questions Hanover County Buyers Ask About FHA and Conventional

Is FHA only for buyers with low credit?

No. It is more forgiving at lower scores, but buyers at any tier can use it. Compare the total cost at your score.

Does a conventional loan always need 20% down?

No. Conventional programs allow as little as 3% to 5% down, with PMI until you reach about 80% LTV.

Can FHA mortgage insurance ever end?

Yes. It ends after 11 years with 10% or more down, or when you refinance or sell.

What is MIP?

Mortgage insurance premium, FHA’s insurance. It has an upfront 1.75% charge and an annual charge billed monthly.

What is PMI?

Private mortgage insurance, charged on conventional loans with less than 20% down. It can be removed at set LTV points.

Does a lower rate mean a lower total cost?

Not necessarily. Mortgage insurance, upfront fees and how long you keep the loan all change the total.

What is a NoTouch Credit Pull?

It is a soft pull pre-approval with no credit hit, no cost, no fees and no commitment.

Can I use gift money or assistance?

Often yes, with documentation. Rules differ by program, and Virginia Housing sets its own requirements.

Does the home’s condition matter?

More with FHA, because HUD minimum property standards can require repairs before closing.

Can I switch from FHA to conventional later?

You can refinance if you qualify. Compute the break-even first, because costs and values change.

Where to Start: Three Numbers Before Everything Else

Do items 1 through 3 first: your credit tier, the mortgage insurance cost over the years you will hold the loan, and your total cash to close. Those three decide most FHA vs. conventional questions. Then check the property and income items, and keep the refinance exit in mind as a possible next step, not the reason you pick a loan.

Start with a NoTouch Credit Pull and a Dare to Compare quote from Duane Buziak at Hanover Mortgage by Duane Buziak, 804-212-8663. More than 2,000+ verified reviews across all platforms are available if you want to see how others found the process.

Ready to see what you qualify for in Hanover County? Duane Buziak, VA Broker of the Year 2024 and 2025 and a Scotsman Guide Top Originator, runs a soft credit check first so there is no hard inquiry on your credit report. Call 804-212-8663 or Apply Now. Duane Buziak NMLS #1110647 | Equal Housing Opportunity.

Share:

More Posts

Conventional Loan vs FHA: Which Fits?

Duane Buziak Explains Mortgage Refinance Options in Hanover County, VA

Duane Buziak Mortgage Maestro, NMLS #1110647, explains mortgage refinance options for Hanover County, VA homeowners, starting with a worked $300,000 example comparing 7.0% and 6.0% payments. The guide matches each goal, whether a lower payment, shorter term, cash, or dropping mortgage insurance, to the refinance type and the cost test that shows whether it pays off in 2026.

Send Us A Message